sleeve club-style crackers (from a 13.7-oz. box, about 38 crackers), plus more as needed 3/4 c. (1 1/2 sticks) salted butter packed light brown sugar vanilla bean paste or vanilla extract Pinch of ...

1-½ cups Red Gumdrops, quartered (Set aside about 25 gumdrop pieces for top) - I purchased 3 of the "Theater Box" size of ...