American Eagle said shoppers are pulling back on spending as it issued mixed holiday-quarter results. The apparel retailer beat on the bottom line and posted comparable sales that came in better than expected.

American Eagle (NYSE:AEO) is surrendering a knee-jerk gain of as much as 11% in after-hours trading as the company’s warnings about first quarter and full year sales offset better-than-expected fourth quarter profits and a beat on comparable store sales.

For all of 2024, American Eagle generated total net revenue of $5.3 billion, a 1% increase from the year before, with total comparable sales for the year up 4%, slightly above the 3% of the year before. Comp sales for women's intimates retailer Aerie increased 5% last year while American Eagle's increased 3%.